Wired Magazine: Why the Army Doesn’t Train on Xboxes.

Right now, every military command post and every training center…

Right now, every military command post and every training center is packed with PCs. In the future, many of those machines might be replaced with game consoles — if the armed forces can ever work out their disagreements with the console-makers.

Why consoles? For starters, it’s a tool that young recruits are very familiar with. The military — especially the Army and Marines — has turned to videogames because live training is often complicated and expensive. Surveys show that young people now spend more time gaming on consoles than on PCs. It’s the older (well, at least over 30) crowd who prefer to play games on computers, and that crowd is likely to shrink over time. If the Pentagon is going to rely on games, then it makes sense to use a platform designed for games, as well as one that’s familiar to your audience.

Another attraction is the hardware. Consoles seem to offer some advantages over computers when it comes to training games. The Nintendo Wii controller (Microsoft and Sony are developing similar hardware) allows a training game to incorporate body movement. A Wii-like console could be useful for individualized physical training for soldiers who need to shed a few pounds, or for practicing individual combat drills when there is no training range available. And then there is the relatively straightforward configuration of consoles, compared to the nightmare that military game developers face in getting games to work on the mishmash of video and sound cards in the government’s potpourri of computers.

So will the Army go out and buy the Xbox? Not quite. Roger Smith, chief technology officer for PEO STRI, the Army command responsible for purchasing training equipment, claims that Microsoft refused to sell him the consoles. Smith told me that he discussed acquiring the Xbox with Microsoft representatives at a trade show back in 2006. According to Smith, the Microsoft executives said they would neither sell the Xbox 360 nor license XNA game development tools to the Army for three reasons:

  • Microsoft was afraid that the military would buy up lots of Xbox 360s, but would buy only one game for each of them, so MS wouldn’t make much money off of the games.
  • A big military purchase could create a shortage of Xbox 360s.
  • If the Xbox became an Army training device, it could taint its reputation. Microsoft was concerned that “do we want the Xbox 360 to be seen as having the flavor of a weapon? Do we want Mom and Dad knowing that their kid is buying the same game console as the military trains the SEALs and Rangers on?” Smith told me during an interview for Training & Simulation Journal.

Read the rest of Michael Peck’s article at wired.com.

Load Comments
  • Edward

    The bit about a shortage of 360s for civilian buyers was completely relevant at the time that the same was rejected. As for the other bit, about the military’s purchasing habits…

    Can you say “Red Ring of Death”?

  • BC

    That’s interesting. I’m surprised that they use PCs and computers at all. There was only one type of training simulation that echoed the feeling of a video game that I felt was the most logical, and realistic interactive training tool. It was an indoor firing range, where we were in full gear, had M4s that fired lazers at a screen, with Co2 canisters hooked up to them to simulate recoil. On the projection screen different live action scenarios would pop up, an angry crowd in a street, a traffic control point, and we had to take out targets while responding appropriately to the escalating situation, and not have any civilian casualties.

    Training on anything else just seems kind of dumb, since you’re not experiencing the physical discomfort of wearing a lot of equipment, holding, aiming, and firing a weapon where your marksmanship fundamentals come into play, and you can use appropriate firing positions.

  • Sal Matos

    Give me a break Microsoft!! As I was reading the headline I knew which way this story was going to end. I’m gonna puke